Tears and Trauma in Tivoli, Inappropriate Remarks and A “Goat Pen” to be Renamed: Friday, September 11, 2015


This has been an interesting week. All kinds of discoveries and revelations seem to be popping up in rather unexpected places. It’s election time, and grand announcements are also the order of the day. Oh, and by the way, the drought continues (at least in Kingston). Which reminds me…

Water: How about this idea, Ministry of Water? Regular updates on the state of our water resources and what is being done to ease the pain. Farmers are literally crying in their dead fields. Residents of St. Mary in particular have been protesting all week. Inner city residents are desperate.  Also, how about regular updates on what is now being done to ensure a reliable and clean supply of water in the future? Thank you.

Doing an excellent job: Sir David Simmons, chairman of the West Kingston Commission of Enquiry, at the Jamaica Conference Centre in downtown Kingston. (Photo: Gleaner)
Doing an excellent job: Sir David Simmons, chairman of the West Kingston Commission of Enquiry, at the Jamaica Conference Centre in downtown Kingston. I believe he is conducting proceedings with great fairness, reason, empathy and close attention. (Photo: Gleaner)

The Commission of Enquiry into the 2010 incursion by security forces in Tivoli Gardens resumed this week. The testimony is increasingly harrowing, and hard to listen to at times. Ms. Jane McFarlane, who was elsewhere at the time of the attack, told the agonizing story of her last conversation with her injured nephew over the phone, following which she called the police, directing them to her house and asking them to help him. When she saw his body, she said, half his face was blown away; she feels she betrayed him to the police. On her return to her home, she found every room filled with blood; three family members had been killed there, including her son. One wonders if psychological counseling took place (and whether it has been sustained) since the violence; I would like to know more about this. Post Traumatic Stress Disorder is a hell of a thing and the Enquiry is leading us into a very, very dark place.

Tears poured down the face of Marjorie Hinds as she testified at the Commission of Enquiry into the Tivoli Gardens incursion, this week. (Photo: Jamaica Observer)
Tears poured down the face of Marjorie Hinds as she testified at the Commission of Enquiry into the Tivoli Gardens incursion, this week. Other witnesses who lost family members also broke down during proceedings this week. (Photo: Jamaica Observer)

” A thinking man’s election” (and woman’s?) This is how Anthony Hylton (he of the failed “Krauck and Anchor” logistics project) described the upcoming polls, in one of his most fiery speeches yet. If I was living in the depressed community of New Haven, I know what I would be thinking. Mr. Hylton described all kinds of plans for his constituency: a waste to energy project at the Riverton dump; warehouses for the logistics hub at Seaview Gardens; and more! Mr. Hylton has been Member of Parliament (MP) for the area since 2007. What has he done for places like Duhaney Park (a struggling residential area with potholes for roads) and New Haven (where garbage, construction waste and the occasional dead body is dumped)? Well, let the constituents believe in the MP’s promises, if they wish. It’s up to them.

Patching things up a bit: President of the Montego Bay Chamber of Commerce and Industry Gloria Henry on Monday met with some members of the Chinese business community. (Photo: Jamaica Observer)
Patching things up a bit: President of the Montego Bay Chamber of Commerce and Industry Gloria Henry on Monday met with some members of the Chinese business community. (Photo: Jamaica Observer)

Remarks by Gloria Henry, Montego Bay businesswoman and head of the town’s Chamber of Commerce and Industry, last week made many Jamaicans very uncomfortable. Ms. Henry struggled to put into some kind of context her comment that Montego Bay citizens should not do business “with people who are not giving back to the community” – singling out Chinese business people. She stressed this week that she was referring to difficulty getting support for a specific city cleanup project (and Lord knows downtown Montego Bay needs a cleanup). A side issue (and one that is telling) is that she seemed to make it clear that she was not referring to the long-established Chinese business community in the town, but perhaps to the “new Chinese.” But then, do the new ones owe Jamaica anything? They are here to make money. I feel sure that Ms. Henry’s words have not been helpful; it’s hard to take back that kind of thing.

EU walks away from project: There was disturbing news recently that the European Union, a major funder of the energy services company (ESCO) project in Jamaica, has pulled the plug after very slow progress in implementing the four-year program, due to end in March 2016. No new contracts will be financed. The Jamaica Productivity Centre headed by Dr. Charles Douglas (who took over just a few months ago) has not been very productive, it appears. As if we are not already in enough of an energy quagmire! What say you, Minister Paulwell?

Commissioner of Police Dr Carl Williams (right) greets Terrence Thompson, the twin brother of Corporal Tyrone Thompson after Terrence paid tribute to his deceased sibling. (Photo: Llewellyn Wynter)
Commissioner of Police Dr Carl Williams (right) greets Terrence Thompson, the twin brother of Corporal Tyrone Thompson after Terrence paid tribute to his deceased sibling. (Photo: Llewellyn Wynter)

More police officers are being arrested: Despite the appalling crime rate, I still have much faith in Commissioner of Police Williams, and hope that he and his senior officers will hang in there and carry on down the anti-corruption road they are pursuing. Commissioner Williams says he is very concerned about the high levels of criminality and corruption in the Jamaica Constabulary Force, but seems determined to weed it out. This week, the very down to earth Assistant Commissioner of Police Elan Powell confirmed that a police officer was involved in the abduction and murder of Alpha McQueen in Old Harbour, who was taken from his home and shot dead. Police Constable Ennis was arrested and charged with another man just over a week ago. When asked why this had not come to light earlier, ACP Powell said most emphatically: “There will never be any cover up…There is no reason to hide it.”

The Simon Bolivar Cultural Centre opened in downtown recently.
The Simon Bolivar Cultural Centre opened in downtown recently. I hope it will be put to good use.

The PetroCaribe shindig culminated with the opening of the Simón Bolívar Cultural Centre in downtown Kingston. It’s a nice building. I am not sure what is going to happen there – Spanish classes? Lectures? Exhibits? Quite sad though that Member of Parliament for the area, the Jamaica Labour Party’s Desmond McKenzie, was apparently not invited. This is not correct protocol, and looks as if the event was politicized. But then, PetroCaribe and the Venezuela relationship has always been politicized. Former Prime Minister PJ Patterson, inevitably, made a speech at the Montego Bay Summit, ending with the word “Venceremos!!” (yes, two exclamation marks on the JIS website). He says he and his dear friend Hugo discussed the possibility of a Hugo Chavez Academy in Jamaica, focusing on specialist education in the fields of language, sports, culture, tourism, environment, maritime training and nursing.”  Mr. Patterson added: “Work on the discipline and design has already reached the embryonic stage…” We shall see what materializes.

Usain Bolt in training
Usain Bolt in training. I would love to see the National Stadium named after him, personally. But the jury is out…

Talking about naming, the Sports Minister announced this week that the Trelawny Multi-Purpose Stadium (which is a misnomer, as it is simply a stadium; the multi-purpose courts have never been built) will be reinvented as the Usain Bolt Sports Academy (Mr. Bolt is a Trelawny native). The Stadium was built specifically for the ICC Cricket World Cup in 2007, at a cost of J$9 billion with a loan from the Chinese government, on land designated for National Housing Trust housing. The World Cup opening ceremony and a few warm-up games took place there. Since then, apart from an annual jazz festival, I believe, it is not used. I understand it is now a “goat pen” and generally considered a huge “white elephant.” Big announcements have also been made to revive the National Stadium (which in my view should be named after Mr. Bolt – he is more than deserving of this honor) – including a National Sports Museum. Where the money is going to come from for all this is not yet clear; another huge loan from the Chinese, perhaps?

All this comes in the wake of the revelation that many of our athletes are really struggling financially. Discus thrower and Olympian Jason Morgan became very emotional when describing how two days before he was supposed to compete for Jamaica at the 2015  World Championships, his supervisor messaged him asking him when he would be back at work. A member of the mile relay team, Ricardo Chambers, has started a Gofundme account to raise funds for next year’s Olympics.

These small parrot fish are on sale in a Kingston supermarket, labeled "South Coast Catch." (Photo: Facebook)
These small parrot fish are on sale in a Kingston supermarket, labeled “South Coast Catch.” (Photo: Facebook)

I’m disturbed to see small parrot fish for sale in Kingston, apparently caught on the south coast and packaged. I wrote in my article on Portland Bight and Old Harbour Bay that there are great concerns that the catch of parrot fish should be greatly restricted, as they actually create our beautiful (and disappearing) white sand beaches and protect the coral reefs – and these are too small! Please…stop. No parrot fish, no reefs, no beaches.

Huge “big ups” to the following…

Suzanne Stanley presents a prize to students of West Indies College Prep in her previous capacity as JET’s programme director. (Photo: JET/Jamaica Observer)
New Deputy CEO at Jamaica Environment Trust Suzanne Stanley presents a prize to students of West Indies College Prep in her previous capacity as JET’s programme director. (Photo: JET/Jamaica Observer)

Ms. Suzanne Stanley:  An amazingly bright, hard-working young woman who has just been promoted to Deputy CEO at Jamaica Environment Trust (JET). I know that Suzi (whom I have known for longer than I care to mention!) will do a marvelous job. Good luck and more power to her!

Concerned, proactive citizens clean up Negril. (Photo: NEPT/Facebook)
Concerned, proactive citizens clean up Negril. (Photo: NEPT/Facebook)

Our western resort town of Negril seems to be in a mess. There are all sorts of infrastructural issues, trees being cut down and strange planning decisions. But it is great to see the Negril Environmental Protection Trust (NEPT) recently got together with local partners to do a major town clean up. This is what NEPT says about it: “Negril is in a deplorable condition as it relates to solid waste management. A holistic approach should be taken to combat such an issue. Organizations, community members, individuals and other stakeholders should play their part to improve solid waste management. 84 bags of garbage were collected by NEPT’s team, fisherfolks, members of the Hanover and Negril Rotary Club, community members and a team from Couples Negril. In total the garbage collected weighed approximately 1863 lbs. This was done on September 2, 2015.” Kudos!

Exuberant fun at the launch of "Talk Up Yout'" this week. (Photo: Loop Jamaica)
Exuberant fun at the launch of “Talk Up Yout'” this week. (Photo: Loop Jamaica)

Big ups to Emprezz Golding, who keeps going with her television show “Talk Up Yout.” More than a TV show, it is giving a voice to our young people – especially teenagers. I am sorry I missed attending the launch of the new series at the Half Way Tree Transportation Centre this week, but I wish Ms. Golding, executive director and presenter, tons of love and good luck. It’s not an easy thing to take on, by the way; but she is connecting.

The JCF reports that 826 people have been murdered up to September 6 – 200 more than last year. St. James is the most “murderous” parish. Clarendon  Westmoreland and Hanover are not doing well either. Now the JCF notes that this year to date more murders have taken place in rural areas than in the “corporate area” – that is, Kingston, St. Andrew and St. Catherine. I don’t recall this ever happening before. What reason has been given for this? I have not heard a convincing explanation, yet. And what IS happening in Clarendon?

Dwayne Phillips, 36, Tavern Crescent, Kintyre, St. Andrew

Andrew Gayle, 24, Collie Smith Drive/Trench Town, Kingston (killed by police)

“Matthew,” Logwood Park/Constant Spring Grove, Kingston (killed by police)

Kerete DeSouza, 30, Narine Lane/Old Harbour, St. Catherine (last week)

Michael Coore, Frankfield, Clarendon

Smith, Frankfield, Clarendon

Winston Reid, 18, Bucks Common/May Pen, Clarendon

Omar Osbourne, 34, Bucks Common/May Pen, Clarendon

Errol Beckford, 61, Gully Back/Canaan Heights, Clarendon

Jane Jones, 54, Gully Back/Canaan Heights, Clarendon

Dwayne Brock, 35, Sandy Bay, Clarendon

Edwin, Montego Bay, St. James

Omar Brown, 19, Retirement, St. James

Leon Clarke, 27, Catherine Hall, St. James

Nathan Joel Alpert, 30, Green Island, Hanover

Rosheen Ferron, 25, Salt Marsh, Trelawny

The grandmother of 24-year-old Andrew Gayle mourns his death. Gayle was allegedly shot dead by the police while picking ackees in Trench Town. (Photo: Loop Jamaica)
The grandmother of 24-year-old Andrew Gayle mourns his death. Gayle was allegedly shot dead by the police while picking ackees in Trench Town. (Photo: Loop Jamaica)

14 thoughts on “Tears and Trauma in Tivoli, Inappropriate Remarks and A “Goat Pen” to be Renamed: Friday, September 11, 2015

      1. I am not sure how I can find out more (perhaps the police could help, or I can go back and find the original media report). It is so very sad, and I send you my sympathies.

        Like

      2. Thank you, I cry more for the daughter he left behind, I’ve been going online trying to find anything pertaining to him unfortunately I haven’t been having any luck. The last time we communicated was Sept 9th which was the last time I heard from him. I guess I was looking for any details anything regarding a service. I wanted to pay my respects not the way I wanted to visit Jamaica again.

        Like

    1. It is VERY sad, and as you say – we are such a small country! Unnecessary and tragic, indeed. 😦 We do need to wake up. Remember that sad list only covers the past five days!

      Like

      1. I do! I especially like (an odd word choice) that you list the names of those who have been murdered. They are more than just statistics and we really shouldn’t forget that or their names.

        Like

      2. Yes. That is exactly my point. I feel we should NEVER forget those whose lives have been taken away so violently (whether they were “good guys” or “bad guys” is completely irrelevant). Nor should we forget those left behind – those who are mourning, whose lives depended on these Jamaicans (mostly young men) – and those who are traumatized. Family members who have witnessed the murder of a loved one, for example. How do you get over that? Are these people getting help? For example, this week a man was shot dead in his house in front of his 73-year-old mother, and sometimes it’s a child who sees the murder of his/her father. Can you imagine the pain and trauma? This is why I continue to list the names. It may seem morbid and sensational, but that is not the intention. It is just a terrible cloud hanging over us, in my view.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s