What about Jamaica’s Trayvons? And why do we laugh at Jamaicans who cry for justice?

I am posting below an article by young Jaevion Nelson, a youth activist with a clear-eyed view of life in Jamaica. Here he touches on a couple of issues that have preoccupied us quite a bit on the social media, and which I referred to in last Sunday’s post. I am reproducing below his column in the “Gleaner” newspaper, published today and available at http://jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/20130718/cleisure/cleisure3.html.

“We need justice, not lip service justice. We demand that all our furniture be replaced. Everything has been destroyed. Regrettably, no one, except the cameraman, has visited as yet to see what has happened. This is unacceptable! We need justice! Justice is what we need for everyone, especially given the predicament we are now in.”

That is an English version of what the young lady from 211/2 Sunlight Street in Kingston 13, who was recently flooded out, who has become the newest local Internet celebrity, was trying to say to the nation – to whomever cared to listen to her concerns.

I am yet to see the kind of outrage and anger from Jamaicans about what happened to these people as there has been around the verdict in the court case involving George Zimmerman for the death of Trayvon Martin who was shot on February 26, 2012 in Sanford, Florida. In fact, many of my (Internet) friends on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram, including those who laughed uncontrollably at the young lady, have changed their profile pics to show solidarity with people of colour in America. In the most uncanny way we have all of a sudden become social justice protesters – posting and tweeting because there must be #JusticeForTrayvon, but hastily and happily sharing the ‘Funny Jamaican Interview’. Does Trayvon Martin deserve justice any more than the people of 211/Sunlight Street?

“Wi need justice, real justice wi need. Justice wi need. I waan bak wi furniture. An a nuh 30 gran bed in deh, an nuh 30 gran dresser or nuh 30 gran fridge or nuh 30 gran whatnat or nuh 30 gran, or ten gran night table, touch lamp, eveybadi! Flatscreen in deh mash up! Flood out wid gully wata. Nuh badi nuh come fi look, only di camera man. It cyaan work suh! “Wi need justice!”

‘fun and games’

Regrettably, because of the language she used, which many of us think is only good for ‘fun and games’; and the so-called dramatic way she employed to register her distress, we didn’t hear her screams for help. We laughed more than we cared, as we did when Clifton ‘Cliftwang’ Brown told us that they desperately needed a bridge in his community. And we still laugh because the people are ‘deading’ without realising the grave situation of some of the most vulnerable Jamaicans.

We aren’t as outraged about the arbitrary indecent language law, which we were reminded about as a result of the death of 26-year-old Kayann Lamont from St Thomas, who was eight months pregnant.

Would you care if Trayvon was Jamaican; if he was your gardener’s son; if he was the little boy who washes your car on Sundays when you’re too tired to go to the car wash? Trayvon Martin could be any one of us so I understand the level of disquiet.

I understand our outrage. I, too, am saddened about his death. I suspect we are so emotionally connected to this case because of the depth of investigation and persistence by the American media (something local journalists desperately need to learn).

vexing issues locally

However, while I have no issue with persons expressing outrage, I would love if we would use this to reflect on some vexing issues locally. Injustice knows no boundaries but we should always use one incident to help us be better in our immediate surroundings.

To be honest, I am ecstatic that so many Jamaicans are committed to the ideas of justice. However, as my colleague Rodje Malcolm (who volunteers with Jamaicans for Justice) said – transfer the outrage! Where exactly was this outrage for the 219 persons killed by the police force last year? Where was this deep and passionate concern for the children who suffer in state care? Where was this bursting need to act for the victims of Armadale? Where are the tears for the hundreds of inner-city young men who are profiled (George Zimmerman Style) by the security forces?

There are many Trayvons in Jamaica. We interact with them every day. Sadly, perhaps because of my work, I know and know of too many Jamaican Trayvons. Poor people, women and girls, sex workers, the disabled, black/dark skinned Jamaicans, people living in low-income communities, lesbians, gays, bisexual and transgender people, children, especially those who are poor, come in conflict with the law or need care and protection, and people living with HIV are our everyday Trayvons.

“At the end of the day, as [we] all change our profile pictures to symbolic hoodies and incessantly tweet #JusticeForTrayvon, I would humbly suggest that you avert your teary eyes to your own backyard and get upset about the injustice on our little island ‘paradise’ as well.” (Rodje Malcolm)

 

Jaevion Nelson is a youth development, HIV and human rights advocate. Email feedback to columns@gleanerjm.com and jaevion@gmail.com.

 


14 thoughts on “What about Jamaica’s Trayvons? And why do we laugh at Jamaicans who cry for justice?

  1. We need a revolution! The world we live in is a very scary place. The fact that Trayvon’s family has a platform afforded by their socio-economic background is a hard pill to swallow. The young lady that has now become an ‘Internet Celebrity’ is a classic example of how (we) Jamaicans value ourselves and how we value people around us.

    Like

  2. I agree with you. It seems Jamaicans of a certain class feel less empathy for our own struggling masses and the injustices sometimes meted out by the police, or just the very nature of being poor and hopeless. We all know class matters in Jamaica. It’s better now, but sometimes it seems like there is no compassion or our fellowmen who are suffering as long as we go home to our nice homes in the hills, behind gates, safe and secure, and our kids go to schools like Hillel Academy, St. Peter and Paul, Vaz Prep, Campion, Immaculate, Wolmers, Jamaica College and St. Andrew school for girls, etc., with their like. We can wave away, without any thought, the nuisance young boys trying to wash our windows at the stoplights uptown for a pittance.

    On another note, I think the reason the Trayvon Martin case resounds with people so much is obviusly because of the race factor. For Jamaicans who live in the States and those who travel often, it’s scary to think that this might very well happen to one of us. And being middle or upperclass might not make one bit of difference to someone who would just make assumptions on the color of your skin and your manner of dress. It’s a scary thought indeed!

    Like

    1. Yes. Wave away without a thought, indeed. You are so right. But you do have a good point about Trayvon Martin which is a clear one and which I should have mentioned. Many Jamaicans do have family in the United States and must be concerned about something like this happening to their own relatives. Our son has lived mostly overseas since the age of 14 (up until then he grew up in Jamaica) – he attended boarding school and college in the U.S. and now he is living and working in London. I sometimes worried about how he coped with racism, which he must have encountered at some point. I am thankful that he has always been fine (so far) but then perhaps he is privileged too. It’s very complex.

      Like

  3. You’ve hit the nail on the head. Unfortunately, I feel like it’s all too easy for us to lament and act out against injustices that we can play no real role in, than to actively argue about things we have the power to change.

    Like

    1. Yes, it is all too easy. But then if we can’t play a role what else can we do but draw attention to these injustices in the best way we can? And you actually can “actively” do something – by joining some of the many civil rights groups out there, and support NGOs working to lift up marginalized Jamaicans (I serve on the boards of two and it’s very hands on). There are actually things you CAN do…

      Like

      1. People need to know this! We’re so quick to jump on the latest US rights bandwagon (or local hilarious newscast) because those are the things being publicized. One hardly ever hears about NGOs by chance or online.

        Like

      2. Yes, that is the thing. It’s partly that the U.S. media digs so deeply into these cases – you become involved. Our local news is incredibly shallow (and trivial) at times. I wish the local media would delve deeply into even one of the many cases of injustice here…

        Like

      3. Yes, but they’re think that the payoff is not as good. Entertainment sells far easier than tragedy, but our journalists need a little more integrity.

        Like

      4. Of course, it is pure entertainment. But when I watch the news I like something informative and thought-provoking. Doesn’t have to be tragedy per se, but something in-depth…

        Like

  4. I am so grateful for your words! I found the video that went viral as a comedy bith horrific and heartbreaking. I could not see any humor in it whatsoever and even more disappointing and sad was the reactions people had to her passionate pleas for justice. How could anyone think that was funny? I was shocked by some of the people who posted it and commented on the humor of it.
    I too carry the murder of Trayvon in my heart and am keenly aware of the injustice for young, black men everywhere. Thank you for always saying the hard stuff. With great respect, Jeannie

    Like

    1. Yes. I found it depressing, and it’s not the first one – there has been a series of them in the past year or so. It is a habit of Jamaicans to laugh at people who speak in patois, especially when they are under stress. I believe it is a kind of class prejudice and a sense that the emotions felt by poor people are somehow not as important as those experienced by people who can express themselves more fluently, in “proper” English. And I agree – we must be aware of injustice everywhere. Thanks so much for your kind words, Jeannie.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.