“Glad to hear Cliff Hughes describe the UTech episode as ‘homophobic‘. There’s far too much denial. ‘Oh no, We’re not homophobic! Not us!’
So noted a fellow-blogger from Jamaica, Annie Paul (check out her lively blog on Jamaican matters large and small at http://anniepaul.net). Yes, just as I was about to write another short, chirpy post-Sandy blog post, the “episode” or “incident” occurred. It popped up on Twitter around eight o’clock last night, in fact.
Let me backtrack a little first: Cliff Hughes is a local broadcast journalist, whom I have praised before for his strong focus on democracy and human rights – and for his probing, tough interview techniques. And UTech is the University of Technology in Kingston, Jamaica, where this all took place. All what, you may ask? Well, a video appeared on YouTube and almost immediately went “viral,” as the saying goes. The video was entitled “Beat di Fish 2!” – using the latest hate-word for gays in Jamaica. The video appears to show security guards beating up a young man in an enclosed area (the guard house of the aforementioned University) while a mob of mostly young men outside jeered, laughed and encouraged the guards to give the young man a good beating. Some of these young men begged the guards to turn him over to them so they could deal with him.
Why was he being beaten? The student was accused of having sex with another young man (who escaped – I hope he is very safe, somewhere).
The video was withdrawn from YouTube today as it violated their code. It was very hard to watch, and to listen to the baying of the crowd, like hounds when they have cornered a fox in a hunt. That eager yelping sound, that cry for blood. And many of the supporters of the video added their virulent, sickening comments (although thankfully there were more “dislikes” than “likes”). But another shorter, different version was posted on CNN‘s iReport today.
There were many expressions of genuine shock and despair, locally. “I am ashamed to be Jamaican” was a common refrain among those with compassion for their fellow Jamaicans. Civil society groups, notably Jamaicans for Justice and the Civil Society Coalition, have issued statements condemning the incident. Some comments in the social media were more ambivalent, saying the two young men should have been more careful, and “this is how gays are dealt with in Jamaica, right or wrong.” Other comments were more vicious. I will not repeat them.
Another Jamaican broadcaster noted the following on her Facebook timeline: “I am sad and sickened tonight. Security guards at one of our universities beating up a young man because he was allegedly found engaging in homosexual acts. I also continue to wonder at my friends with their heads deep in the sand insisting that we are not a homophobic society. Really? This young man is hit and kicked by a “security “guard” while excited crowds gather outside. And for those who will wilfully twist my words – you are adept at that – this has nothing to do with approval of or belief in a lifestyle. This is about a society that winks at barbarism and turns its head away insisting it is not happening, apparently all the reports of abuse are made up!!! And you wonder why we are seen as homophobic?”
Let us not deny this any more. Jamaica IS a homophobic society. It has been said by many outside and some inside Jamaica. And it is true. It is staring us in the face.
So, what are we to do about it? Allow the mob to take over? After all, there have been several instances of mob attacks recently, under various circumstances. This is not only yet another example of human rights abuses against gays in Jamaica. It fits into a pattern of intolerance, violence and blind ignorance that keeps repeating itself over and over. It is like a tide washing over us, threatening to sweep us all away.
Have you ever stared into the eyes of a hate-filled mob? We once knew someone who did – a young Jamaican. It was the last thing he saw, as he did not survive the attack. None of us could save him. We read his name in the papers the next day.
Where is this leading us? Are we prepared to slip and slide down this slope? Or are we prepared to dig our heels in, right now? Are our leaders going to speak up, or remain silent? I remember not long ago, our elected representatives were sniggering and making jokes about “fish” in Parliament (the derogatory word for gays currently in fashion). Can we expect real, responsible leadership from them? What about our Prime Minister, who during an election debate last year signaled a softer approach to the issue? She has certainly avoided the topic ever since she was elected. And what about the churches? After all, the homophobic bigots frequently use a certain passage in the Bible to justify their hatred. What a lovely thing religion is! How it unites us!
I will end with a quote from someone who did know a great deal about bigotry and discrimination. He faced it fair and square. (Somehow, the deniers of our homophobia hate comparisons between gay rights and the American civil rights struggle; but I see quite a few parallels, myself). Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.
I have decided to stick with love. Hate is too great a burden to bear.
Jamaica’s burden grows heavier each day.
- Jamaica Anti-Gay Attack On Student Allegedly Caught On Tape (huffingtonpost.com)
- Gay Man Beaten By Guards, Mob At Jamaica University: VIDEO (towleroad.com)
- Sunday After Sandy: October 28, 2012 (petchary.wordpress.com)
- Gay Jamaicans launch legal action over island’s homophobic laws (guardian.co.uk)
- Landmark Case Seeks To Abolish Jamaica’s Colonial-Era Anti-Gay Laws (queerty.com)
- A small step forward for LGBT rights in Jamaica (pri.org)
- Help Jamaica please?!? (ireport.cnn.com)
- https://petchary.wordpress.com/2012/08/09/end-patronizing-piecemeal-engagement-of-youth/ (End patronizing, piecemeal engagement of youth: petchary)
- https://petchary.wordpress.com/2011/04/09/rights-and-wrongs/ (Rights and Wrongs: petchary)
- Gay Jamaican Man Caught Having Sex Brutally Attacked By Guard, Mob (queerty.com)
- Gay student beaten at Jamaican University (ireport.cnn.com)
- https://petchary.wordpress.com/2012/04/12/op-ed-fighting-injustice-in-jamaica/ (Op-ed: Fighting injustice in Jamaica: petchary)
- https://petchary.wordpress.com/2012/06/15/dark/ (Dark: petchary)
- http://www.jamaicaobserver.com/news/Marksman-fires-security-guards-involved-in-Utech-beating (Marksman fires security guards involved in UTech beating)
- http://www.jamaicaobserver.com/news/Mob-beats-man-accused-of-killing-pregnant-girlfriend (Mob beats man accused of killing pregnant girlfriend)
- http://www.jamaicaobserver.com/news/UTech-plans-counselling-session-for-beaten-student (UTech plans counseling session for beaten student)
- http://www.jamaicansforjustice.org/nmcms.php?snippets=news&p=news_details&id=3819 (JFJ condemns act of violence against allegedly homosexual young man on UTech campus)
- http://jamaica-gleaner.com/latest/article.php?id=40922 (UTech, Marksman condemn beating of alleged gay student)
- http://jamaica-star.com/thestar/20121102/news/news1.html (UTech student beaten)
- http://jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/20110504/letters/letters1.html (“Mob rule is no rule” – another UTech incident)
- http://jamaica-gleaner.com/gleaner/20121003/cleisure/cleisure3.html (“Put an end to jungle justice” – a recent op-ed)
- https://petchary.wordpress.com/2011/01/30/ode-to-freddy-and-david/ (Ode to Freddy (and David): petchary)
- https://petchary.wordpress.com/2011/12/16/jamaican-maurice-tomlinson-is-the-first-winner-of-the-david-kato-vision-voice-award/ (Jamaican Maurice Tomlinson is the first winner of the David Kato Vision Voice Award: petchary)
32 thoughts on “Sticks and Stones”
This is the right blog for everyone who really wants to understand this topic. You realize a whole lot its almost tough to argue with you (not that I really would want to…HaHa). You certainly put a brand new spin on a subject that has been written about for ages. Great stuff, just excellent!
Thanks very much for your comment. I hope you will follow my blog. I took a look at yours and see that you have just started up. Do continue, and keep in touch! Thanks!
Thanks so much!
How tragic… I hope he’s okay? What a terrible thing to do to another soul. So much wickedness in this world… Help Us Lord!
I think he is probably OK physically. But psychologically and mentally – I cannot imagine. He certainly cannot go back to study at UTech, and nor could his alleged partner either. Wickedness is a word Jamaicans often use – and it sums this up, I think.
This incident is incredibly disturbing. While it’s painful to watch, I don’t know how anyone can look at it and not feel shame at how we humans succomb to violence and mob rule. I’m grateful to you and those you mention for being courageous enough to call others out on this.
Yes, it is so painful. Many Jamaicans did feel shame, on behalf of our fellow citizens. We have to shed some light on this issue…blogging about it is one of the ways…
Very good piece, truthful blunt and honest, it’s time for us to take our heads out of the sand in this country. Intolerance and ignorance is a dangerous combination
Thank you so much, Damian. I wanted to be rather blunt. We need to tell the truth and face it squarely. As you say, behaving like an ostrich is not going to help. Denial is not good for us as a society (it applies to other things too…) Thanks very much for your support.
Thanks for this insightful post. Is there any alliance of pro-gay or anti-homophobic groups in JA that can work together with a stronger voice than each alone? IMHO, the govt is the last place to look for leadership. They will only institute change when the people speak out loudly enough, at least that is what has happened in the USA. It’s been a slow change since Stonewall in the 1960’s. But as Dan Savage’s seminal video project claims, “It gets better.” http://www.itgetsbetter.org/
Yes, there are a few civil society/civil rights groups, such as the two I mentioned in my blog, that are very supportive and put out statements yesterday. So I think the pressure is building and coalitions will slowly grow stronger, as happened in the USA. I am not entirely pessimistic but do believe that we need to face up to this and address it…. “It gets better” is a wonderful and very meaningful campaign. We must always have hope. Thanks so much for your comments, and do come and visit again soon!
Truth is Emma it is captured into these lines from your piece;
“It fits into a pattern of intolerance, violence and blind ignorance that keeps repeating itself over and over. It is like a tide washing over us, threatening to sweep us all away.”Same so mi say plus the burden is not only getting heavier also so much more painful, Guidance and walk safely.
Thank you, T. And you too. It is a very heavy burden, isn’t it. I wish we could just shrug it off our shoulders. Why all the hatred? It cannot move us forward.
I am so shocked by this. Thank you on behalf of all of us here in the cyberworld who knew nothing of this before your post. Thank you for your bravery in speaking out when others just turn away, thankful it’s not them. It’s not about lifestyle choices it’s about freedom of choice and respecting fellow citizens in those choices, whether ‘we’ like them or not. Great piece and keep on bring this injustice to light.
Thanks so much for your comments. Sadly, this has been an issue for quite a while in our country. It is something that could be resolved, however, I believe – if we only embrace love, and the respect that you mention (and which Jamaicans talk about a lot). We need to work at it. And meanwhile, I think the more sunshine that we have on this, the better. It will help.
excellent excellent post. Even if you don’t agree with the lifestyle violence is never the answer.
Thanks so much! Yes, it is as simple as that. Violence is never the answer.
Thanks for the callout and for this post which really captures what happened at UTech and contextualizes it…will reference it when i do my post…
You’re welcome. I wanted to start with that, because it is the “denial” aspect of it that is one of the most galling. We need to own up to this problem, and then deal with it. I look forward to your post later! There is “so much things to say” isn’t there!
I’m not sure ‘like’ is quite what I mean! Nevertheless, a powerful piece.
Thanks, Jack. No, “like” doesn’t seem quite right, does it.